Login

Login
No account yet? Register
 

AddThis Social Bookmark Button

Enter Our Giveaway

CSI NY
  
 
 
 CLICK ON THE COVER TO 

ENTER! 

Site programming by Cory Webb

Cory Webb logo
Doctor Who- New Beginnings 
Reviews DVD Reviews
Written by Nick Lyons   
Saturday, 02 February 2008


Favored by 0 users (Register to add this entry to your favorites)

Grade

Content Grade: B
Sound Grade: B-
Extras Grade: A-
Picture Grade: B-

Specs

BBC Video Fullscreen Mono 98 mins./98 mins./96 mins.

Review

The end of Tom Baker's era, and the start of Peter Davison's run.
"The Keepr Of Traken" finds the Doctor summoned to the peaceful, evil-less world of Traken where he must uncover whom is terrorizing the planet. As much as I like Tom Baker's Doctor, I have to admit that he seems tired here. He just seems to go through the motions and lacks the humor and wit that made his Doctor so popular. It doesn't help that the screenplay is rather lackluster until the riveting final moments in which the Master presents himself. In Tom Baker's swan song "Logopolis," the Doctor tries to stop the maniacal Master from not only destroying the important planet of Logopolis, but destroying the universe itself. Even though this episode features the two worst companions (Tegan and Adric) and some heavy exposition, there's much to admire here. First and foremost, Who fans finally get more insight into the fascinating regeneration process. In addition, it's great to see Anthony Ainley's take on the Master. He may ham it up at times, but his scenes with the Doctor have you glued to the screen. "Castrovalva" finds the Doctor not only struggling with the new regeneration, but struggling to stop the Master from yet another evil trap/plan. It's no secret that regeneration stories are tricky. The main problem with them is that it's hard to get a sense of what the new Doctor is like as he's nearly out of his mind. Plus, it doesn't help that Davison's first episode is rather empty story wise. Luckily, the episode does have several memorable moments such as seeing more of the Tardis interior, Davison picking out his outfit, the introduction of the zero room, learning more about the powers of the Tardis, etc.

AddThis Social Bookmark Button

Picture and Sound

The 4:3 fullscreen picture quality looks like all of the other classic episodes on DVD. Good, but far from great. The Mono audio track is nice and clean, but obviously not up to Dolby Digital quality.

Extras

The Keeper Of Traken: * Photo gallery, info text, isolated music score, 6 mins of trailers and continuity ads, and a "Doctor Who" series 2 ad. * DVD-ROM extras: Radio Times listings and a Dr. Who annual. * Sarah Sutton On Swap Shop (11:15) is an enjoyable interview with the actress on her career. * "The Return Of The Master" (9:40) is a featurette on the return of the Doctor's arch nemesis. * "Being Nice To Each Other" is a 30 minute docu on the costumes, sets, JNT, and early script draft information. * Commentary by Anthony Ainley, Sarah Sutton, Matthew Waterhouse, and Johnny Byrne- Byrne provides some great insight into writing the story and Ainley delivers some good laughs. Logopolis: * Isolated music, photo gallery, continuities, info text, DVD-rom 1982 "Dr. Who" annual/Radio Times listing, and a "Robin Hood" series 1 ad. * A 2 minute news item about Tom Baker getting married and leaving "Doctor Who" and Peter Davison being announced as the Doctor. *A fun little interview with Peter Davison from the "Pebble Mill At 1" show. The highlight: Hand drawn pictures of what fans want Davison's costume to look like. * 8 minutes of interviews with Tom Baker and Peter Davison from the show "Nationwide." * "A New Body At Last" is a 50 minute docu on the changes made to the show as well as Tom's antics on set. A must watch. * Commentary by Tom Baker, Janet Fielding, and Christopher H. Bidmead. Chris goes into depth about the story and metaphors, while Baker makes the track worth listening to with his jokes. Castrovalva: * Info text, continuities, photo gallery, isolated music score, a remixed music video of the opening theme, and the two DVD-ROM extras- 1982 "Dr. Who" annual and Radio Times listings. * A 20 1/2 minute interview with Peter Davison on the show "Swap Shop." A lot of the questions asked were already asked by other interviewers from other extras. * The "Blue Peter" extra is a 9 minute rundown of "Dr. Who" as well as a quick interview with Peter Davison. * "Directing Castrovalva" is an 11 minute interview with director Fiona Cumming. * 1 1/2 minutes of deleted scenes. * "Being Doctor Who" is a 13 1/2 minute featurette with Davison talking about how he got the part and what he brought to the role. * "The Crowded Tardis" is an 11 1/2 minute featurette on the MANY companions. * Commentary by Peter Davison, Janet Fielding, Christopher H. Bidmead and Fiona Cumming. Highlights include everyone playfully making fun of Janet and Davison laughing at his acting.

Summary

"Doctor Who- New Beginnings" is a solid collection of episodes with tons of extras to satisfy any Who fan. Recommended.

User reviews

There are no user reviews for this item.

To write a review please register or login.





Powered by jReviews
 
< Prev   Next >

Featured Review

Apocalypse Now - The Complete Dossier

Category: DVD Reviews
Just like the film, this two-disc set of Francis Ford Coppola's classic is both rewarding and maddening, comprehensive yet incomplete. Of course, no DVD collection is complete without at least one version of the movie, and if nothing else, this set provides a great opportunity to grab "Apocalypse Now" & "Apocalypse Now Redux" at the same time, along with enough bonus features that make it worth replacing any previous DVD for. However, as anyone obsessed with the film will certainly attest to, without the inclusion of the brilliant documentary, "Hearts of Darkness," which chronicled the harrowing movie shoot, this "Dossier" is decidedly incomplete.

Movie Quotes

I have come here to chew bubble gum and kick
ass, and I'm all out of bubble gum.

Roddy Piper
They Live

Latest Reviews

Ladies and Gentlemen, The Fabulous Stains

Ladies and Gentlemen, The Fabulous Stains Ladies and Gentlemen, The Fabulous Stains

Criminal Minds - The Complete Third Season

Criminal Minds - The Complete Third Season Criminal Minds - The Complete Third Season

Iron Man- Ultimate 2-Disc Edition

Iron Man- Ultimate 2-Disc Edition Iron Man- Ultimate 2-Disc Edition

Snow Angels

Snow Angels Snow Angels

Top Gun - I Love the 80's Edition

Top Gun - I Love the 80's Edition Top Gun - I Love the 80's Edition

The Guild- Season One

The Guild- Season One The Guild- Season One

An Autumn Afternoon (Criterion Collection)

An Autumn Afternoon (Criterion Collection) An Autumn Afternoon (Criterion Collection)

The Year My Parents Went On Vacation

The Year My Parents Went On Vacation The Year My Parents Went On Vacation

Smallville- The Complete Seventh Season

Smallville- The Complete Seventh Season Smallville- The Complete Seventh Season

How The West Was One-Ultimate Collection Edition

How The West Was One-Ultimate Collection Edition How The West Was One-Ultimate Collection Edition

Child's Play- Chucky's 20th Birthday Edition

Child's Play- Chucky's 20th Birthday Edition Child's Play- Chucky's 20th Birthday Edition

Jack Brooks- Monster Slayer

Jack Brooks- Monster Slayer Jack Brooks- Monster Slayer

Supernatural- Season Three

Supernatural- Season Three Supernatural- Season Three

Doctor Who- The Invisible Enemy and K-9 And Company

Doctor Who- The Invisible Enemy and K-9 And Company Doctor Who- The Invisible Enemy and K-9 And Company

It's Always Sunny In Philadelphia- Season Three

It's Always Sunny In Philadelphia- Season Three It's Always Sunny In Philadelphia- Season Three
High Definition poll
 

Sept 23, 2008 releases

Affair to Remember
Ax Men - Season 1 (History Channel)
Bashing
The Bill Douglas Trilogy
Billionaire Boys Club
Bloood Sucking Cinema
Boston Legal: Season 4
A Broken Life
Brothers and Sisters: The Complete Second Season
A Chipmunk Christmas 25th Anniversary
Cine Manifest
Cinematographer Style
Copycat
Critical Condition
CSI: New York - The Fourth Season
Deception
Design 2
Dororo
Fall from Grace
Family Name
Far North
Final Exam
Friday The 13th - The Series: The First Season
The Godfather - The Coppola Restoration Gift Set
The Godfather - The Coppola Restoration
The Godfather Part II - The Coppola Restoration
The Godfather Part III - The Coppola Restoration
Grease: Rockin Rydell Edition
High School Musical 2
Horatio Hornblower: Collector's Edition
Icarly: Season 1 V.1
Juan, I Forgot I Don't Remember
L.A. Confidential
Leatherheads
Liberia-An Uncivil War
Lion in the House
Love Conquers All
Midnight Eagle
My Name is Earl - Season Three
Naked Fear
The Neighbor
Passing Poston
Pathology
Price of Sugar
Questioning Faith
Re-Cycle
Reno 911: Miami - More Busted Than Ever Edition
Rome - Rise and Fall of an Empire
Run, Fat Boy, Run
Samantha Who: The Complete First Season
Saturn in Opposition
Savage Streets - Special Edition
Scooby-Doo and the Goblin King
Seoul Raiders
Shooting Henry Hill
Sundown-Vampire in Retreat
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Season 2 - Part 2
This American Life - Season 1
Two and a Half Men - The Complete Fourth Season
Unemployed
Vipers
Virginia Lee Burton-Sense of Place

AddThis Social Bookmark Button