Login

Login
No account yet? Register

Recent DVD Reviews

Teeth (0) (0)
Category: DVD Reviews
Noriko's Dinner Table (0) (0)
Category: DVD Reviews
Wire, The: The Complete Second Season (0) (0)
Category: DVD Reviews
Black Gold (0) (0)
Category: DVD Reviews
Golden Compass, The-New Line Platinum Series Two-Disc Widescreen Edition (0) (0)
Category: DVD Reviews
Wakeful Nights (0) (0)
Category: DVD Reviews
P.S. I Love You (0) (0)
Category: DVD Reviews

Enter Our Giveaway

 

 Savages
 

 

 CLICK THE COVER TO 
ENTER! 

Site programming by Cory Webb

Cory Webb logo
Golden Compass, The-New Line Platinum Series Two-Disc Widescreen Edition  New
Reviews DVD Reviews
Written by DVD David   
Thursday, 08 May 2008


Favored by 0 users (Register to add this entry to your favorites)

Grade

Content Grade: B-
Sound Grade: A
Extras Grade: A
Picture Grade: A+

Specs

Studio/Label Website: http://newline.com
Aspect Ratio: 2.35:1
Sound Options and Formats: Dolby digital 5.1, DTS-EX 6.1 Discrete sound
Disc Length: 113 minutes

Review

The $180 million dollar fantasy, The Golden Compass, which created all sorts of controversy and a banning from the Catholic Church, comes to dvd in this special two disc set, loaded with extras. The film is pure eye candy, with generous special effects and if you don't try to over analyze it, can be taken for what the story is, a children's fantasy tale.
Lead by a cast of familiar favorites and an unknown but talented child star, the film was very ambious but failed to spark audiences. One reason being the story is overly complicated and too much detail is left out to make the story flow. It also suffers from sequel-i-tis-this is meant to be the first of a trilogy and there is a lot left up in the air at the end of this film with no satisfying conclusion.

The film takes place in an alternate world; one in which people's souls are outside their bodies in the form of animals known as daemons. These animals reflect the character of the individual person and interact with them whereever they go. The story involves a young orphaned girl named Lyra (Dakota Blue Richards), who lives a care free tom boyish life at Oxford until she discovers a plot by the evil institution called the Magisterium to squash free thought and separate children from their daemons. She yearns to travel with her uncle (Daniel Craig) who is traveling North to search for mysterious Dust, which supposedly connects worlds together. She is taken away from her home by Mrs Coulter (Nicole Kidman) and taught refinement but before she leaves, she is given a device that allows her to see things-the truth. As she gazes into the compass, she learns more about Mrs. Coulter and runs as soon she can. Her adventures take her northward to look for her uncle in an icy land where she befriends a friendly witch, played by Eva Green (Casino Royale) , an aeronaut (Sam Elliot) and a magnificent fighting bear (voice of Ian McKellen). Her quest turns to restoring the bear to his rightful place as King of the Bears of the North, to find her uncle, and discover what happened to her friends from Oxford, who have disappeared.
Performances to be noted in this fantasy include an excellent debut for Dakota Blue Richards, who really shines in her part. The established stars Kidman and Craig, reunited from "The Invasion", are stiff; especially Craig, who has a minimum of screen time. Kidman is better as Mrs. Coulter, as she is icy evil but also has feeling towards the child. Sam Elliot is Sam Elliot, a cowboy in this world with a jack rabbit daemon with the voice of Kathy Bates. He plays the same character he was in "The Big Lebowski", an all wise and all knowing plain talking cowboy totally out of his element.

As far as the evil empire element o f this land, I can see why Catholics were in an uproar over the film.The costuming of the leaders looks much ike the robes and uniforms of the Church. However, I think that is where the comparison ends. The goals of this institution and the Cathlolic Church are not the same and children, who this story and film are aimed at, will not see the comparison at all.

The picture is one of the best since Lord Of The Rings-The creatures look real, the backgrounds and landscapes are magnificent and the vehicles and devices are imaginative and stunning to look at. In this world, magical Jules Verne type vehicles are the norm and its a delight to watch them. Sound options are also plentiful; DTS-EX 6.1, Dolby 5.1 and Dolby 2.0.

This Platinum two disc set contains a disc full of extras with about 2 and a half hours of documentaries and features. While most are typical making of footage, they do go into depth with sections about the author of the books, Plillip Pullman, thhe young star of the film and how she got the part, the film's less then confident director Chris Weitz (before this he did American Pie), and featurettes on costuming, adaptation of the story, the music, and special effects. The extras are worthy of a second disc as it contains a lot of information in all aspects of the film.

The Golden Compass is an ambitious undertaking and a big gamble for a studio to take. Comparisons to Narnia are obvious; another land, children leading the charge, large battles for dominance, good vs. evil. The makers of the film series have a lot to prove as this opening act is incomplete but the stunning visuals and star power of Kidman and Craig will sell a lot of discs.


User reviews

There are no user reviews for this item.

To write a review please register or login.





Powered by jReviews
 
< Prev   Next >

Featured Review

World Trade Center - Commemorative Edition

Category: DVD Reviews
I'm not sure what's more surprising...the fact that a film based on events from 9/11 could be ultimately so uplifting, or that said-film is directed by such an in-your-face director as Oliver Stone. I know a lot of folks who stayed away from "World Trade Center" either because of its subject matter, or Stone's patented sensationalism. Neither reason is warranted, because like this year's more visceral (and still better) "United 93," this film eschews the hows and whys of 9/11 to focus on the selfless individual heroism present that day. But unlike "United 93," "WTC" is almost totally character-driven, about how those horrific events changed the lives of a few brave men and their families. The result is a long but poignant film that's unlike any Oliver Stone movie you've ever seen.

Movie Quotes

Ilsa, I'm no good at being noble, but it
doesn't take much to see that the problems
of three little people don't amount to a
hill of beans in this crazy world.

Humphrey Bogart
Casablanca

Latest Reviews

Adventures Of Young Indiana Jones,Volume 3, The

Adventures Of Young Indiana Jones,Volume 3, The Adventures Of Young Indiana Jones,Volume 3, The

Lost Highway

Lost Highway Lost Highway

Classic Musicals From The Dream Factory Volume 3

Classic Musicals From The Dream Factory Volume 3 Classic Musicals From The Dream Factory Volume 3

Bonnie And Clyde Two-Disc Special Edition

Bonnie And Clyde Two-Disc Special Edition Bonnie And Clyde Two-Disc Special Edition

Film Noir: Five Classics From the Studio Vaults

Film Noir: Five Classics From the Studio Vaults Film Noir: Five Classics From the Studio Vaults

Jane Austen Book Club

Jane Austen Book Club Jane Austen Book Club

Noriko's Dinner Table

Noriko's Dinner Table Noriko's Dinner Table

Death Of A Cyclist

Death Of A Cyclist Death Of A Cyclist

Lions for Lambs

Lions for Lambs Lions for Lambs

Chinese Godfather, The/ Duel of Karate

Chinese Godfather, The/ Duel of Karate Chinese Godfather, The/ Duel of Karate

Charlie Wilson's War

Charlie Wilson's War Charlie Wilson's War

Botched

Botched Botched

Cloverfield

Cloverfield Cloverfield

Wakeful Nights

Wakeful Nights Wakeful Nights

BBC Atlas Of The Natural World- Africa and Europe

BBC Atlas Of The Natural World- Africa and Europe BBC Atlas Of The Natural World- Africa and Europe

May 13 , 2008 releases

The Arab Conspiracy
Bet Your Life
The Big Trail
The Bite
Botched
Carve Her Name With Pride
The Cottage
Criterion Collection: Fire Within
The Daydreamer
Demon Pond
Drawn Together - Uncensored: Season Three
Fistful of Dynamite
Fox Western Classics
Frank Sinatra - The Early Years Collection
Frank Sinatra - The Golden Years Collection
The Frank Sinatra and Gene Kelly Collection
Frontier
A Good Man Is Hard To Find
Graduation
The Great Debaters (2-Disc Special Collector's Edition)
HDNet Fights: Fedor Returns
Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade
Indiana Jones and the Raiders of the Lost Ark
Indiana Jones and the Temple of Doom
Lost in Beijing
Lovejoy - The Complete Season 3
The Lovers - Criterion Collection
Mad Money
Magnificent Seven Collection
Magnificent Seven: The Complete Series
Man of the West
The Master
Mission: Impossible The Fourth TV Season
National Lampoon's Cattle Call
None But the Brave
A Raisin in the Sun
The Rat Pack Ultimate Collectors Edition
The Rat Patrol: The Complete Series
Saturday Night Live The Complete Third Season - Limited Edition Boxed Set
The Secret Invasion
She
Sinatra
Stargate Infinity: Complete Series
Two and a Half Men: The Complete Third Season
Untraceable
Wager
Walk All Over Me
Youth Without Youth