Login

Login
No account yet? Register
 

AddThis Social Bookmark Button

Recent DVD Reviews

The Big Bang Theory- Season One (0) (0)
Category: DVD Reviews
Camp Rock- Extended Rock Star Edition (0) (0)
Category: DVD Reviews
House, M.D. Season Four (4.0) (0)
Category: DVD Reviews
Heroes Season 2 (0) (0)
Category: DVD Reviews
Affinity (0) (0)
Category: DVD Reviews
Smart People (0) (0)
Category: DVD Reviews
Gossip Girl - The Complete First Season (0) (0)
Category: DVD Reviews

Enter Our Giveaway

What Happens
  
 
 
 

 

 CLICK ON THE COVER TO 
ENTER! 

Site programming by Cory Webb

Cory Webb logo
I Am Legend (Single Disc) 
Reviews DVD Reviews
Written by Nick Lyons   
Tuesday, 01 April 2008


Favored by 0 users (Register to add this entry to your favorites)

Grade

Content Grade: D+
Sound Grade: A
Extras Grade: D+
Picture Grade: B

Specs

Studio/Label: Warner Home Video
Aspect Ratio: 2.35:1
Sound Options and Formats: Dolby Digital 5.1
Disc Length: 100 Minutes

Review

"I Am Legend" is a deeply flawed adaptation of a classic novel.

The story: Robert Neville and his pet dog are the last survivors of a virus that killed everyone in the world (or so Robert thinks) and transformed them into mad, vampire like creatures called Dark Seekers. Aside from gathering supplies and looking for signs of life, Robert spends most of his lonely time trying to find a cure. Will he succeed? Will he find any survivors?

As a huge fan of Richard Matheson’s novel, I was quite dissatisfied by this film adaptation as the extensive use of CGI completely took me out of the film. “Omega Man” may be a dated and deeply flawed adaptation, but I found the opening scenes in a REAL deserted Los Angeles to be highly effective and chilling. True, “I Am Legend” does have some real location shooting, but the F/X team covers everything up with their own post-apocalyptic vision. Worst of all, the F/X team makes the movie’s villains (The Dark Seekers) entirely CGI. Not since “Van Helsing” have I been so embarrassed by CGI creations. Just look at the Dark Seeker people with the dogs and try not to laugh.

Another issue I had with the script by Akiva Goldsman and Mark Protosevich is that they threw in random bid budget action sequences and some cringe worthy scenes involving Robert talking to Mannequins and acting out “Shrek.” Not only do these scenes not play well on screen, but they are far too long and take up valuable screen time.

The only redeeming quality of this adaptation was the acting by Will Smith and the dog. It’s a shame that Will Smith keeps doing these safe Hollywood vehicles as he is wasting his talent. He needs to take meatier roles such as he did in “Ali.”


AddThis Social Bookmark Button

Picture and Sound

The 2.35:1 widescreen picture quality wasn't quite up to snuff. I couldn't help but wish I was watching the HD DVD or Blu-Ray version instead as it would have made the cityscapes look cleaner and sharper.

The Dolby Surround 5.1 audio track is far better than this movie deserves. The action, the dialogue, the sounds of the city are all crystal clear.

Extras

4 animated comics, DVD-ROM extras, and trailers for "Lost Boys 2," "The Dark Knight," "Speed Racer," "Appleseed Ex Machina," "Justice League: New Frontier," and Blu-Ray and HD-DVD ads.

User reviews

There are no user reviews for this item.

To write a review please register or login.





Powered by jReviews
 
< Prev   Next >

Featured Review

Sopranos, The The Complete First Season

Category: DVD Reviews
Those of us who love movies are by nature suspicious of the hype machine, by the outrageous pull quotes festooning newspaper ads, for This Week's Movie Of the Century!!!!, more often than not from blowhard reviewers we've never heard of. And though in my lifetime I've probably spent more time watching television than any other single activity, I'm particularly wary when a series is touted as the greatest work of art in a quarter-century (by the New York Times, no less), when there seems to be some mad competition between critics over who can offer the most lavish praise. And so I came to "The Sopranos" late, for fear that it had been oversold, that it couldn't live up to the hype. I've seen way too many mob movies, and a lot of the more recent ones have just been treading water, picking over the dead carcasses of familiar territory; and it's been a good long while -- dating to when I got my DVD player, probably -- since I got hooked on a television show. But you know what? Just when I thought I was out, they pull me back in. The pilot episode is a little masterpiece of the form, and the twelve episodes rounding out the season are full of drama, color, texture, of life.

Movie Quotes

Remember, you're fighting for this woman's
honor, which is probably more than she ever
did.

Groucho Marx
Duck Soup

Latest Reviews

DEXTER the second season

DEXTER the second season DEXTER the second season

Mon Oncle Antoine - Criterion Collection

Mon Oncle Antoine - Criterion Collection Mon Oncle Antoine - Criterion Collection

Legend of the Shadowless Sword, The

Legend of the Shadowless Sword, The Legend of the Shadowless Sword, The

Heroes Season 2

Heroes Season 2 Heroes Season 2

Camp Rock- Extended Rock Star Edition

Camp Rock- Extended Rock Star Edition Camp Rock- Extended Rock Star Edition

House, M.D. Season Four

House, M.D. Season Four House, M.D. Season Four

Virgin Territory

Virgin Territory Virgin Territory

American Mall, The

American Mall, The American Mall, The

Miss Pettigrew Lives for a Day

Miss Pettigrew Lives for a Day Miss Pettigrew Lives for a Day

Picture This!

Picture This! Picture This!

Affinity

Affinity Affinity

Get Smart- The Complete Series

Get Smart- The Complete Series Get Smart- The Complete Series

My Sassy Girl

My Sassy Girl My Sassy Girl

Ferris Bueller's Day Off - I Love the 80's Edition

Ferris Bueller's Day Off - I Love the 80's Edition Ferris Bueller's Day Off - I Love the 80's Edition

Terminator - The Sarah Connor Chronicles - Season One

Terminator - The Sarah Connor Chronicles - Season One Terminator - The Sarah Connor Chronicles - Season One
High Definition poll
 

Sept.2 releases

Amadeus
Art of Travel
Bait Shop
Before I Forget
The Big Bang Theory - The Complete First Season
The Blue Elephant
The Boys in Company C
The Case of the Grinning Cat
Cheers: The Tenth Season
Derek
Desperate Housewives: The Complete Fourth Season
Eli Stone: The Complete First Season
Ferocious
Fist of Legend
Ghost Whisperer: The Third Season
Honey West: The Complete Series
How to Rob a Bank
The Inspector Lynley Mysteries 6 Set
It's the Great Pumpkin, Charlie Brown
Lagerfeld Confidential
The Last Bolshevik / Happiness
Life: Season One
Little People, Big World: Season 2, Volume 1
Married Life
Mickey Mouse Clubhouse: Mickey's Storybook Surprises
Monarchy-Royal Family at Work
Monster Camp
The Morgue
My Friends Pooh & Tigger: Hundred Acre Wood Haunt
Next Avengers: Heroes Of Tomorrow
The Office: Season Four
The Office: Seasons 1 - 4 Collection
Outsourced
Remembrance of Things to Come
The Sensation of Sight
Shelley Duvalls Faerie Tale Theatre-Complete Series
The Sixth Side of the Pentagon / The Embassy
Supernatural - The Complete Third Season
Then She Found Me
Transformers Blu-Ray
War Requiem
Water Lilies


AddThis Social Bookmark Button