Login

Login
No account yet? Register
 

AddThis Social Bookmark Button

Enter Our Giveaway

CSI NY
  
 
 
 CLICK ON THE COVER TO 

ENTER! 

Site programming by Cory Webb

Cory Webb logo
Over There-Season One 
Reviews DVD Reviews
Written by DVD David   
Monday, 27 March 2006


Favored by 0 users (Register to add this entry to your favorites)

Grade

Content Grade: A
Sound Grade: A
Extras Grade: B
Picture Grade: A

Specs

Fox Home Entertainment Dolby 5.1, Spanish 2.1 Widescreen 1.78:1 Subtitles in English, Spanish, French, CC 585 minutes,color, 2005

Review

Producer Steven Bochco (NYPD Blue, Hill Street Blues) took a big chance on this series about the current war in Iraq. Casting mostly unknowns in this intense and uncompromising series, Brochco has made a show that is powerful, thought provoking, and action packed without political overtones. That in itself is a triumph in today's Hollywood. But the show received criticism from conservatives and Fox caved in, cancelling it after 13 episodes.
Season One contains 5 discs and includes all the episodes plus some extras. The basic story follows a group of our forces who arrive in Iraq and each episode deals with a different aspect of the war, which many of us have come to be familiar with from the nightly news. Brochco also focuses the show on lives back home, which makes the show much more powerful.
While the troops, led by ER alum Erik Palladino as "Sgt. Scream" Silas, find themselves on patrol, in firefights, covering up CIA work, on road block duty and other scenarios, the families back home deal with a number of problems surrounding the loss of their loved ones. Luke McFarlane plays an intellictual private who has an alcholic wife at home. Nicki Aycox as Brenda "Mrs. B." Mitchell finds out that her son has major medical problems, comes home and goes AWOL. Josh Henderson, who is Mr. Gung-Ho in the pilot epsiode is badly injured and wants to become the first amputee to return to Iraq. Omid Abtahi plays Tariq Nassiri, an Arab from Detroit, who joined after 9-11. He brings a powerful performance as Henderson's replacement, battling his own men over prejudices and finding out more about his own culture.
The cast is terrific and Brochco made the right move with casting unknowns for the parts, giving the entire series a more realistic feel. He also features women in the fight, with Mrs. B and Lizette Carrion as Pfc. Esmeralda "Doublewide" Del Rio, whose husband is at home and starts to flirt with a support group wife.
I also liked the use of current technology, as the soldiers video e-mail their loved ones and have live video conferences in tents setup with Internet feeds and laptops.

AddThis Social Bookmark Button

Picture and Sound

Shooting in and around Chatsworth, California, the production values of the series are very good and the sets really take on the look and grittiness of Iraq. War battle scenes are depicted with great realism and the gore factor is at times pretty intense. This is especially true in the pilot and with the special effects used with "amputee" Josh Henderson. Be prepared for legs and arms being blown off, intestines and chests visibly open and some soldiers totally blown away into small pieces.
Sound is a good 5.1 surround with lots of subwoofer info during battles. It will shake the roof if cranked.
One thing also; the song, "Over There", written by Chris Gerolmo plays at the end of each episode and really just go to well with the series. I can see it being used on the pilot but each episode was a bit much. Whatever impact it had at the beginning of the series is lost by the fifth or sixth show, and it becomes a song that you dread to hear, much like the opening song of "Star Trek: Enterprise".

Extras

The discs contain three commentaries on selected episodes, and lengthy making of documentary and a weapons debriefing. While the extras list is short, these extras are well thought out and of high quality with cast member interviews, much input from Stephen Brochco and Chris Gerolmo.

Summary

A powerful, dramatic show that took a lot of bold chances portraying our troops in a current war. A talented young cast, tight writing, and realistic sets make this an entertaining series. Too bad it didn't survive the political heat. Now we can enjoy it on DVD for a reasonable price.

User reviews

There are no user reviews for this item.

To write a review please register or login.





Powered by jReviews
 
< Prev   Next >

Featured Review

Alfie (2004)

Category: DVD Reviews
Not that I feel sorry for people like Jude Law, but it must be kind of tough being impossibly good looking in Hollywood. Guys like Brad Pitt do their best to downplay their looks, hoping to be taken seriously. While such folks occasionally do a film that doesn't trade in on their good looks, they're still likely to remain movie stars, not actors, for the rest of their careers (Robert Redford had to go behind the camera to get some artistic credibility). Then there's guys like Law, who accepts the cruel fate God has bestowed upon him and puts it to good use. We'll never buy him as a hard-ass cop or psycho serial killer, but to coin a cliche, he was born to play guys like the title character in "Alfie," a remake of the 1966 classic.

Movie Quotes

I have come here to chew bubble gum and kick
ass, and I'm all out of bubble gum.

Roddy Piper
They Live

Latest Reviews

Some Kind of Wonderful - I Love the 80's Edition

Some Kind of Wonderful - I Love the 80's Edition Some Kind of Wonderful - I Love the 80's Edition

Cinematic Titanic- The Wasp Woman

Cinematic Titanic- The Wasp Woman Cinematic Titanic- The Wasp Woman

Curb Your Enthusiasm: The Complete Third Season

Curb Your Enthusiasm: The Complete Third Season Curb Your Enthusiasm: The Complete Third Season

Sports Night: The Complete Series (10th Anniversary Edition)

Sports Night: The Complete Series (10th Anniversary Edition) Sports Night: The Complete Series (10th Anniversary Edition)

Rob & Big - The Complete Third Season

Rob & Big - The Complete Third Season Rob & Big - The Complete Third Season

Ballad of Narayama, The

Ballad of Narayama, The Ballad of Narayama, The

Pushing Daisies - The Complete First Season

Pushing Daisies - The Complete First Season Pushing Daisies - The Complete First Season

Brotherhood of the Wolf - Director's Cut

Brotherhood of the Wolf - Director's Cut Brotherhood of the Wolf - Director's Cut

Risky Business (Deluxe Edition)

Risky Business (Deluxe Edition) Risky Business (Deluxe Edition)

Bill Douglas Trilogy, The

Bill Douglas Trilogy, The Bill Douglas Trilogy, The

Moontide (Fox Film Noir)

Moontide (Fox Film Noir) Moontide (Fox Film Noir)

Smallville- The Complete Seventh Season

Smallville- The Complete Seventh Season Smallville- The Complete Seventh Season

Year My Parents Went On Vacation, The

Year My Parents Went On Vacation, The Year My Parents Went On Vacation, The

Medium-The Fourth Season

Medium-The Fourth Season Medium-The Fourth Season

Torchwood- The Complete Second Season

Torchwood- The Complete Second Season Torchwood- The Complete Second Season
High Definition poll
 

Sept 23, 2008 releases

Affair to Remember
Ax Men - Season 1 (History Channel)
Bashing
The Bill Douglas Trilogy
Billionaire Boys Club
Bloood Sucking Cinema
Boston Legal: Season 4
A Broken Life
Brothers and Sisters: The Complete Second Season
A Chipmunk Christmas 25th Anniversary
Cine Manifest
Cinematographer Style
Copycat
Critical Condition
CSI: New York - The Fourth Season
Deception
Design 2
Dororo
Fall from Grace
Family Name
Far North
Final Exam
Friday The 13th - The Series: The First Season
The Godfather - The Coppola Restoration Gift Set
The Godfather - The Coppola Restoration
The Godfather Part II - The Coppola Restoration
The Godfather Part III - The Coppola Restoration
Grease: Rockin Rydell Edition
High School Musical 2
Horatio Hornblower: Collector's Edition
Icarly: Season 1 V.1
Juan, I Forgot I Don't Remember
L.A. Confidential
Leatherheads
Liberia-An Uncivil War
Lion in the House
Love Conquers All
Midnight Eagle
My Name is Earl - Season Three
Naked Fear
The Neighbor
Passing Poston
Pathology
Price of Sugar
Questioning Faith
Re-Cycle
Reno 911: Miami - More Busted Than Ever Edition
Rome - Rise and Fall of an Empire
Run, Fat Boy, Run
Samantha Who: The Complete First Season
Saturn in Opposition
Savage Streets - Special Edition
Scooby-Doo and the Goblin King
Seoul Raiders
Shooting Henry Hill
Sundown-Vampire in Retreat
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Season 2 - Part 2
This American Life - Season 1
Two and a Half Men - The Complete Fourth Season
Unemployed
Vipers
Virginia Lee Burton-Sense of Place

AddThis Social Bookmark Button