Enter Our Giveaway
CLICK ON THE COVER TO ENTER!
Site programming by Cory Webb
|
|
Reviews DVD Reviews
|
|
Written by Dave Anderson
|
|
Monday, 23 July 2007 |
|
Favored by 0 users
(Register to add this entry to your favorites)
Grade Content Grade:
B
Sound Grade:
A
Extras Grade:
A+
Picture Grade:
A
Specs Buena Vista 1.78:1 Enhanced Widescreen; 1.33:1 Fullscreen English 5.1 Dolby Digital Surround; French & Spanish Tracks English SDH, Spanish & French Subtitles 40 min., color, 2006 Rated G Review by Dave Anderson
Review
The one inherent drawback to an IMAX film on DVD is obvious. It's not going to have the same visual impact at home, no matter what size your home theater screen. Which means the film needs to be an interesting enough documentary to be worthwhile. When viewed anywhere besides an IMAX theater, most of 'em aren't. While Disney's "Roving Mars" is probably far more impressive on a six-story screen, it still manages to be a pretty good film on DVD, both visually and narratively. Ironically, what really makes this disc a keeper is a vintage Walt Disney documentary from the 1950's "Disneyland" series, included as a bonus feature (even though it's actually longer than the movie itself).
Using both real footage and CGI, "Roving Mars" documents the efforts of NASA to launch and land two robotic land rovers, named Spirit & Opportunity, on the surface of our closest planetary neighbor. The early scenes, where we are subjected to obligatory comments from enthusiastic brainiacs working on the project, are kind of draggy, but once that's out of the way and the rovers are launched, the awe inspiring visuals take over. Of course, the actual footage of the surface of Mars is amazing, but so are the seamlessly inserted CGI effects, which help to enhance the story. In true Disney fashion, the film does a good job personifying these robots, so we almost feel sympathetic when the narrative ominously reminds us they will never return from this desolate planet. As a documentary, "Roving Mars" works pretty well, and does a good job making us appreciate just how amazing this feat really was. But, scene after scene, I kept saying, "I'll bet this was REALLY cool on an IMAX screen." As impressive as the visuals are, they just aren't going to instill that same sense of awe on a flat screen TV, no matter how big yours is.
Picture and Sound
Despite the unavoidably lessened visual impact on DVD, this disc sports a great transfer. It is presented in both 1.78:1 widescreen and 1.33:1 fullscreen (the latter being the original IMAX aspect ratio). The audio is rendered in 5.1 Dolby Digital, and it sounds great, with great, creative balance.
Extras
While the film itself is a decent documentary, one of the two extras is a lot more fun. "Mars: Past, Present & Future", featuring comments from the filmmakers and JPL Rover team, is simply okay, maybe worth checking out once. But the 1957 "Disneyland" series episode, "Mars and Beyond," is lots of fun. Running an hour long, this documentary uses some amusing and (for its time) impressive animation to, not only recount the history man's study of the stars, but speculate on what might be waiting for us if we were ever to visit other worlds. Fanciful, and sometimes silly, it's nevertheless marvelously entertaining.
Summary
The visual impact of "Roving Mars" is severely diminished on home video, but even as a documentary, it's narratively better than most IMAX films. And after a slow start, it's visually impressive, even suspenseful at times. For me, though, the best part of the disc is the old "Disneyland" episode, which my kids and I have already enjoyed twice. That alone makes me recommend this disc.
User reviews
There are no user reviews for this item.
To write a review please register or login.
|
Featured Review
Freddy vs. Jason is ridiculous, idiotic, high-concept garbage...98 minutes of gratuitous nudity, over-the-top violence, bad dialogue, and stupid teenagers who mostly exist just to die. But what's great about the movie is that it's made by folks who know they are making ridiculous, idiotic, high-concept garbage. Even die-hard fans of the Nightmare on Elm Street and Friday the 13th franchises have to admit there's no possible way to take this clash-of-horror-titans seriously. Still, this decade-in-development opus was arguably the most anticipated horror film in recent memory, mainly because the idea of taking two modern pop culture icons and sticking them in the same movie is awesome in its simplicity, and more importantly, hasn't been attempted in decades. Since both individual franchises have withered on the vine, I personally appreciate the what-the-hell-let's go-for-it attitude on display here. And truth be told, it's one of the few films released in 2003 which seems hell-bent on pleasing its audience, giving genre fans exactly what they have been waiting so long to see. What's really surprising is the fact that New Line could have simply pumped out yet another generic DVD with minimal extras, but instead took the time and effort to present the film as a double-disc set, absolutely loaded with a ton of informative and fun extras that fans of both franchises will love.
Movie Quotes
We're on a mission from God. Dan Aykroyd Blues Brothers
|
|
Sept.2 releases
Amadeus Art of Travel Bait Shop Before I Forget The Big Bang Theory - The Complete First Season The Blue Elephant The Boys in Company C The Case of the Grinning Cat Cheers: The Tenth Season Derek Desperate Housewives: The Complete Fourth Season Eli Stone: The Complete First Season Ferocious Fist of Legend Ghost Whisperer: The Third Season Honey West: The Complete Series How to Rob a Bank The Inspector Lynley Mysteries 6 Set It's the Great Pumpkin, Charlie Brown Lagerfeld Confidential The Last Bolshevik / Happiness Life: Season One Little People, Big World: Season 2, Volume 1 Married Life Mickey Mouse Clubhouse: Mickey's Storybook Surprises Monarchy-Royal Family at Work Monster Camp The Morgue My Friends Pooh & Tigger: Hundred Acre Wood Haunt Next Avengers: Heroes Of Tomorrow The Office: Season Four The Office: Seasons 1 - 4 Collection Outsourced Remembrance of Things to Come The Sensation of Sight Shelley Duvalls Faerie Tale Theatre-Complete Series The Sixth Side of the Pentagon / The Embassy Supernatural - The Complete Third Season Then She Found Me Transformers Blu-Ray War Requiem Water Lilies
|