Login

Login
No account yet? Register

Recent DVD Reviews

Teeth (0) (0)
Category: DVD Reviews
Noriko's Dinner Table (0) (0)
Category: DVD Reviews
Wire, The: The Complete Second Season (0) (0)
Category: DVD Reviews
Black Gold (0) (0)
Category: DVD Reviews
Golden Compass, The-New Line Platinum Series Two-Disc Widescreen Edition (0) (0)
Category: DVD Reviews
Wakeful Nights (0) (0)
Category: DVD Reviews
P.S. I Love You (0) (0)
Category: DVD Reviews

Enter Our Giveaway

 

 Savages
 

 

 CLICK THE COVER TO 
ENTER! 

Site programming by Cory Webb

Cory Webb logo
A Passage To India 
Reviews HD Reviews
Written by DVD David   
Friday, 18 April 2008


Favored by 0 users (Register to add this entry to your favorites)

Grade

Content Grade: A
Sound Grade: A
Extras Grade: B+
Picture Grade: B+

Specs

1080p
Studio/Label: Sony Pictures
Studio/Label Website: http://sonypictures/bluray
Aspect Ratio: 1.66:1
Sound Options and Formats: Dolby TrueHD 5.1
Disc Length: 164 minutes

Format

Format: Blu-Ray

Review

David Lean's last film is also Sony's launch of their "Classic" series on Blu-Ray. It is a good disc to premier the series as it brings together beautiful cinematography, a mysterious storyline, and great performances from the entire cast. The story is adapted from E.M. Forster's novel, also a classic. Lean tried to be as faithful to the novel as possible, with few exceptions.

The story involves a young woman, Miss Quested (Judy Davis) who travels to 1923 India with her future mother-in-law, Mrs. Moore(Peggy Ashcroft) to meet her fiance Ronny(Nigel Havers), who is a local magistrate. Davis got an Oscar nomination for her performance. Upon her arrival, she is appalled over the treatment of the local people, and the British prejudice towards them. She is also mysteriously drawn to a set of caves, high above the city. She meets a progressive Englishman, (James Fox), who introduces her to some locals; one a Hindi professor at thecollege (Alec Guiness) and a local Dr.Aziz (Victor Banerjee). Guiness' role was controversial because he was English but Lean wanted him there and Guiness accepted. His role is a bit like Obi-Wan, a man who knows much more than he tells.
Dr.Aziz proposes a picnic trip up above the city to the caves with the two women and they eagerly accept. It is on that trip where things don't go as planned and the story takes a unique and bizarre twist.

This long film has many beautiful shots of India and its people. Shot in 1984, there was no CGI to paste people in; the masses are real and Lean, a master at his craft, shows us a magnificent country. Most impressive are the different shots of water in the film, from flowing streams from a railroad tressel, to mighty rivers reflected in the moonlight.

The Blu-Ray transfer is what I was most interested in, as this is an older film and it came through with just a few flaws. The print used is absolutely clean from start to finish. The only thing that brought the picture grade down a notch were a few scenes that really showed a lot of film grain. Colors are punchy and skin tones are excellent. Alec Guiness must have gone through a lot of time in makeup because he was as brown as a nut. Details are unbelievably sharp on the Indian officers uniforms and many indoor scenes.

The soundtrack is offered in English and French Dolby TrueHD 5.1. The mix is very good and all speakers are utilized to enhance the India experience as much as possible, from the crowded marketplace, which totally surrounds you, to the mysterious echoes in the caves.

Extras included on the disc are both old and new and are offered in both standard and high definition. Surviving members of the crew offer insights into the production and working with Lean, who was 81 during filming, while cast members (Nigel Havers, James Fox and others) offer their recollections of working on the film. It was disappointing not to have comments from Davis though, since she played such a key role in the film. The disc also includes a graphics in track feature (sort of a fancy pop-up ) which is well worth a look. Commentary is provided by RIchard Goodwin, producer of the film. Lastly, there is old footage of Lean speaking about this filmand his other films in different segments; only wished it had been longer, as it only lasts about 10 minutes.

"A Passage To India" is not the greatest film directed by Lean; that debate could go on for days as he produced so many great ones but it is a grand finale for the talented director. This Sony Blu-Ray disc offers a beautiful picture and story, excellent cast and substantial extras for a fine introduction to their "Classic" line of films.


User reviews

There are no user reviews for this item.

To write a review please register or login.





Powered by jReviews
 
< Prev   Next >

Featured Review

A Room With A View HD-DVD

Category: HD Reviews
It is well known that Merchant Ivory collaborations (namely "The Remains Of The Day" and "Howard's End") are critical darlings. In addition to scoring countless awards, their films have consistently been a success at the box office. But to me, however, they are kryptonite. I detest the Merchant Ivory period pieces so much in fact, that they come only second to Ashton Kutcher vehicles in my hall of pain list. Of course, in reviewing DVDs and HD-DVDs, you're bound to come across a Merchant Ivory film sooner or later. As it turns out, James Ivory's 1985 film "A Room With A View" wound up in my hands. The good news: It's probably the most tolerable of their work. The bad news: It's still a Merchant Ivory film.

Movie Quotes

Have you ever danced with the Devil in the
pale moonlight?

Jack Nicholson
Batman

Latest Reviews

Juno-Blu-Ray

Juno-Blu-Ray Juno-Blu-Ray

Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid-Blu-Ray

Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid-Blu-Ray Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid-Blu-Ray

Master and Commander-The Far Side Of The World-Blu-Ray

Master and Commander-The Far Side Of The World-Blu-Ray Master and Commander-The Far Side Of The World-Blu-Ray

A Passage To India

A Passage To India A Passage To India

Adventures Of Baron Munchausen

Adventures Of Baron Munchausen Adventures Of Baron Munchausen

May 13 , 2008 releases

The Arab Conspiracy
Bet Your Life
The Big Trail
The Bite
Botched
Carve Her Name With Pride
The Cottage
Criterion Collection: Fire Within
The Daydreamer
Demon Pond
Drawn Together - Uncensored: Season Three
Fistful of Dynamite
Fox Western Classics
Frank Sinatra - The Early Years Collection
Frank Sinatra - The Golden Years Collection
The Frank Sinatra and Gene Kelly Collection
Frontier
A Good Man Is Hard To Find
Graduation
The Great Debaters (2-Disc Special Collector's Edition)
HDNet Fights: Fedor Returns
Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade
Indiana Jones and the Raiders of the Lost Ark
Indiana Jones and the Temple of Doom
Lost in Beijing
Lovejoy - The Complete Season 3
The Lovers - Criterion Collection
Mad Money
Magnificent Seven Collection
Magnificent Seven: The Complete Series
Man of the West
The Master
Mission: Impossible The Fourth TV Season
National Lampoon's Cattle Call
None But the Brave
A Raisin in the Sun
The Rat Pack Ultimate Collectors Edition
The Rat Patrol: The Complete Series
Saturday Night Live The Complete Third Season - Limited Edition Boxed Set
The Secret Invasion
She
Sinatra
Stargate Infinity: Complete Series
Two and a Half Men: The Complete Third Season
Untraceable
Wager
Walk All Over Me
Youth Without Youth