Login

Login
No account yet? Register
 

AddThis Social Bookmark Button

Recent DVD Reviews

The Big Bang Theory- Season One (0) (0)
Category: DVD Reviews
Camp Rock- Extended Rock Star Edition (0) (0)
Category: DVD Reviews
House, M.D. Season Four (4.0) (0)
Category: DVD Reviews
Heroes Season 2 (0) (0)
Category: DVD Reviews
Affinity (0) (0)
Category: DVD Reviews
Smart People (0) (0)
Category: DVD Reviews
Gossip Girl - The Complete First Season (0) (0)
Category: DVD Reviews

Enter Our Giveaway

What Happens
  
 
 
 

 

 CLICK ON THE COVER TO 
ENTER! 

Site programming by Cory Webb

Cory Webb logo
Star Trek- The Original Series: Season One (HD-DVD/DVD) 
Reviews HD Reviews
Written by Nick Lyons   
Sunday, 18 November 2007


Favored by 0 users (Register to add this entry to your favorites)

Grade

Content Grade: B
Sound Grade: B+
Extras Grade: A-
Picture Grade: B+

Specs

Paramount 24 hours 35 minutes

Review

The "Star Trek- The Original Series" Season 1 HD-DVD/DVD combo was my most anticipated set of the year. When the copy arrived in my hands, I immediately popped the set in and dove right into the episodes and extras. While the episodes themselves vary in quality, this fully loaded 10 disc set does not disappoint.
The 29 episode first season may seem dated to some viewers, but you have to realize how groundbreaking this show truly was for television and the science fiction genre. Gene Roddenberry's vision of the future resonated with people as it showed a universe filled with equality, peace, and hope. The crew of the Enterprise may have encountered their fair share of hostile aliens and humans, but much of the time they attempted to resolve conflicts peacefully. It is because of these stories and themes that Trek contains to prevail 40 years later. To celebrate the 40th anniversary, Paramount/CBS have released this new Original Series Season 1 set with new ship, planet, phaser f/x and remastered prints and music. Purists may take issue with the new inclusions, but I can honestly say that the changes are slight and seamlessly blend into the show. Besides, the show was due for a restoration. If you take a look at the previous DVD releases, the prints were hideously faded and overly grain. Like with many shows, the first season is hit and miss. For every classic like the Romulan encounter episode "Balance Of Terror," the infamous Kirk Vs. Gorn story "Arena," the introduction of Captain Christopher Pike in "The Menagerie," and the first appearance of Kaaaaaaaaahn in "Space Seed," we get unwatchable episodes such as "The Alternative Factor," "Miri," and "What Are Little Girls Made Of?" One of the main flaws of the show, however, was that the episodes tended to be too focused on Spock, Kirk, and Bones. While Spock is certainly the most "fascinating" character, I am sure I am not alone in wishing there were more Sulu, Scotty, and Uharu centric episodes. Granted, these characters got more screen time in the feature films, but I never felt the writers fully explored their characters. Overall, season one can't compare with the brilliant season two, but it's still loaded with fun, characterization, and throught provoking themes and stories. In other words, it's sci-fi at its best.

AddThis Social Bookmark Button

Picture and Sound

The 4:3 fullscreen picture quality may be grainy in spots, but so what? This set is superior in every way to previous TOS DVD releases. How can you complain about the gorgeous newly added f/x and the beautifully remastered prints? It seems illogical to me. Th English Dolby TrueHD and English 2.0 Surround tracks are also nicely remastered. Every line delivery, computer beep, phaser fire, booming music score is perfectly audible.

Extras

All 10 discs are double-sided. Side A contains the HD-DVD versions, while side B contains the standard DVD version. The extras are as follows: Disc 1 Side A- The Starfleet Access feature is included on the episode "Where No Man Has Gone Before" and can be played during the episode. It is essentially a feature that allows viewers to read or watch information about the episode, ships, locations, and so forth. Side B- Preview trailers and a 20 minute featurette titled "Spacelift: Transporting Trek Into The 21st Century." The CBS/Paramount team give an inside look at how they remastered the episodes and compare the old prints to the new newly redone prints. Disc 2 Side B- "The Birth Of A Timeless Legacy" (24:43) discusses how Trek came to be, the original pilot "The Cage," how Spock got his hears, and other goodies I won't reveal. Preview trailers are also included. Disc 3 Side B- Preview trailers and "Reflections On Spock" (12:12). Leonard Nimoy goes into great depth about his character and his book "I Am Not Spock." Disc 4 Side A- Two "Starfleet Access" features on "The Menagerie" Part 1 and 2. Side B- Preview trailers and a featurette titled "Life Beyond Trek: William Shatner" (10:27) in which William Shatner shares his love of horses. Disc 5 Side A- Starfleet Access feature on "Balance Of Terror." Side B- Preview trailers and "To Boldly Go...Season One." This 19 minute featurette takes a look at the various episodes (namely "Naked Time" and "Space Seed"). Disc 6 Side A- Starfleet Access feature on "The Galileo 7." Side B- "Sci-Fi Visionaries" discusses the scripts and the brilliant minds behind them. Preview trailers also included. Disc 7 Side B- "Billy Blackburn's Treasure Chest: Rare Home Movies And Special Memories" is an enjoyable 13 1/2 minute look at Blackburn's experiences on set as minor characters. Let us not forget the preview trailers. Disc 8 Side A- "Space Seed"- Starfleet Access Side B- Along with preview trailers, there are 2 featurettes on this disc ("Kiss 'N' tell: Romance In The 23rd Century" and "Trekker Connections"). Naturally, "Kiss" (8:33) talks about the various romances on the show and the feature length films (most of which concern Kirk and Scotty and Uharu). "Trekker" is a game in which you connect various actors and actresses that have appeared on Trek shows. Disc 9 A- "Errand Of Mercy" Starfleet Access feature. B- Preview trailers. Disc 10 Side A- "Spacelift: Transporting Trek Into The 21st Century" and "Billy Blackburn's Treasure Chest: Rare Home Movies And Special Memories." A "Star Trek Online Game Preview" and an "Inetractive Enterprise Inspection" are also included. Side B- "Star Trek Online Game Preview," preview trailers, and my favorite extra "Star Trek: Beyond The Final Frontier." Leonard Nomoy hosts this 90 minute special and guides viewers through the massive geektastic Christie's Trek Auction sale and various opinions on why Trek continues to thrive. While "Frontier" already aired on television, it's still a great special to have on disc.

Summary

"Star Trek TOS: Season one" is a must own for all trekkies, trekkers, and HD-DVD player owners. Season 2 can't come fast enough.

User reviews

There are no user reviews for this item.

To write a review please register or login.





Powered by jReviews
 
< Prev   Next >

Featured Review

End Of Days Blu-Ray

Category: HD Reviews
This "Arnold" vehicle was the first film he did after his heart problems and it shows he should have been more careful to pay off his Dr. bills.  Arnie plays a security guard who is alcoholic and suicidal after the death of his wife and child.  While I can give a good nod to Arnold's progression as an actor in this film, the plot and lapses in logic boggle the mind.
Co-stars include a decent cast led by Kevin Pollack as his sidekick, Gabriel Byrne as Satan, Rod Steiger as a priest and Robin Tunney as the girl Arnie needs to rescue.

Movie Quotes

Get your stinking paws off me, you damned
dirty ape!

Charleton Heston
Planet Of The Apes

Latest Reviews

Robin Hood- Season One Blu-ray

Robin Hood- Season One Blu-ray Robin Hood- Season One Blu-ray

Robotech- The Shadow Chronicles Blu-ray

Robotech- The Shadow Chronicles Blu-ray Robotech- The Shadow Chronicles Blu-ray

The Counterfeiters Blu-ray

The Counterfeiters Blu-ray The Counterfeiters Blu-ray

Clear and Present Danger Blu-Ray

Clear and Present Danger Blu-Ray Clear and Present Danger Blu-Ray

Baby Mama Blu-ray

Baby Mama Blu-ray Baby Mama Blu-ray

Camp Rock- Extended Rock Star Edition Blu-ray

Camp Rock- Extended Rock Star Edition Blu-ray Camp Rock- Extended Rock Star Edition Blu-ray

CJ7 Blu-ray

CJ7 Blu-ray CJ7 Blu-ray

Dude, Where's My Car Blu-ray

Dude, Where's My Car Blu-ray Dude, Where's My Car Blu-ray

Nixon Blu-Ray

Nixon Blu-Ray Nixon Blu-Ray

Dragon Ball Z- Dead Zone/The World's Strongest Blu-ray

Dragon Ball Z- Dead Zone/The World's Strongest Blu-ray Dragon Ball Z- Dead Zone/The World's Strongest Blu-ray

Street Kings Blu-ray

Street Kings Blu-ray Street Kings Blu-ray

Terminator: The Sarah Connor Chronicles Season One Blu-ray

Terminator: The Sarah Connor Chronicles Season One Blu-ray Terminator: The Sarah Connor Chronicles Season One Blu-ray

Justice League- Season One Blu-ray

Justice League- Season One Blu-ray Justice League- Season One Blu-ray

The Scorpion King 2: Rise of A Warrior Blu-ray

The Scorpion King 2: Rise of A Warrior Blu-ray The Scorpion King 2: Rise of A Warrior Blu-ray

Afro Samurai- Season 1 Director's Cut Blu-ray

Afro Samurai- Season 1 Director's Cut Blu-ray Afro Samurai- Season 1 Director's Cut Blu-ray
High Definition poll
 

Sept.2 releases

Amadeus
Art of Travel
Bait Shop
Before I Forget
The Big Bang Theory - The Complete First Season
The Blue Elephant
The Boys in Company C
The Case of the Grinning Cat
Cheers: The Tenth Season
Derek
Desperate Housewives: The Complete Fourth Season
Eli Stone: The Complete First Season
Ferocious
Fist of Legend
Ghost Whisperer: The Third Season
Honey West: The Complete Series
How to Rob a Bank
The Inspector Lynley Mysteries 6 Set
It's the Great Pumpkin, Charlie Brown
Lagerfeld Confidential
The Last Bolshevik / Happiness
Life: Season One
Little People, Big World: Season 2, Volume 1
Married Life
Mickey Mouse Clubhouse: Mickey's Storybook Surprises
Monarchy-Royal Family at Work
Monster Camp
The Morgue
My Friends Pooh & Tigger: Hundred Acre Wood Haunt
Next Avengers: Heroes Of Tomorrow
The Office: Season Four
The Office: Seasons 1 - 4 Collection
Outsourced
Remembrance of Things to Come
The Sensation of Sight
Shelley Duvalls Faerie Tale Theatre-Complete Series
The Sixth Side of the Pentagon / The Embassy
Supernatural - The Complete Third Season
Then She Found Me
Transformers Blu-Ray
War Requiem
Water Lilies


AddThis Social Bookmark Button